Agriculture Minister Luis Planas this week defended keeping CAP payments for retired farmers to prevent land abandonment. Spain’s regions are split almost 50/50. In Valencia’s Ribera Alta, where abandonment is widespread, a young farmer says the aid changes nothing.

Planas said the payments should also reach farmers who work “occasionally or part-time”, retirees included. His argument: “If we stop paying these subsidies, the result could be desertification through abandonment, and that’s the worst thing that could happen to us.”

Meanwhile, Brussels admits a 100,000 million euro cut to the CAP budget, and there are proposals on the table to scrap aid for retirees and cap payments to large recipients at 100,000 euros. The new programme would come into force on 1 January 2028.

“It gets abandoned anyway”

The farmers we spoke to describe a different reality on the ground. Eduardo, a farmer in the Ribera Alta — Villanueva de Castellón, Carcaixent — doesn’t buy the diagnosis: “They say the land would be abandoned. I don’t believe it: it gets abandoned anyway. Sure, you get a little something, but it’s more of a symbolic gesture from Europe than anything else. Just look at the yearly abandonment figures.”

For him, abandonment isn’t about subsidies, it’s about pests. “There’s more and more abandonment, mainly because the pests we’re up against are really hard to control. Keeping them in check takes a huge number of treatments, which drives up costs and squeezes the margin. Older people don’t want to spend their retirement on that anymore, and the CAP doesn’t cover it: it’s a pittance.”

On the aid itself, he’s blunt: “A farmer should make money, should be able to live off what he earns. The fact that we have the CAP is proof of the failure of Spanish farming.”

1,500 euros per hanegada

Land prices in his area show just how far things have fallen. “As a young guy I’ve bought for less than 2,000 euros per hanegada. The norm is around 1,500.” That’s roughly 18,000 euros per hectare. Getting land, he says, “is dead easy where I am, because everything’s abandoned.”

Older owners hang on out of attachment, not profit. “It’s their parents’ and grandparents’ land, and it hurts to let it go. That’s the real reason many keep going. If you offer them their price, they sell straight away. And they can’t just abandon it either, because the costs keep coming: pruning, water.”

The way out: the internet

His alternative had nothing to do with subsidies. “We young farmers have turned to the internet. We set up the Campos del Abuelo platform to stand up for ourselves, because it’s the only way: sorting your own transport, after-sales, the right boxes to ship orders, the way to reach customers. We’ve got to the point where we can’t depend on anyone.”

Negotiations on the next CAP are still open, and Planas has already warned that a transition period may be needed if they’re not wrapped up in time.


Sources: Infobae — The Government wants retirees to keep receiving CAP payments · Agrodigital — Planas defends extending CAP aid to retirees · Moncloa — Brussels admits a 100,000 million cut to the CAP

— Redacción Campos del Abuelo