The Supreme Court ruling on ecological flows in the Tagus, announced on 23 September, mainly affects the areas that depend on the Tagus-Segura transfer, where the cut for 2027 reaches 105 cubic hectometres shared between Alicante, Murcia and Almería. But the rising cost of irrigation water isn't a problem limited to those areas.
A farmer from a municipality that irrigates entirely from the Júcar river, with no transfer involved at all, explains it with two very specific numbers.
“Three years ago we paid twelve cents”
“We're paying roughly twenty cents per cubic metre, when three years ago we paid twelve or thereabouts,” he says. The increase, he insists, has nothing to do with water availability: in his municipality “there's no shortage of Júcar water.” He puts it down entirely to the cost of electricity, which powers the pumps and irrigation systems.
Twelve cents three seasons ago and twenty now is 67% more, without a single litre of available flow changing.
What you give up before they cut you
Asked what he'd stop planting first if his water were ever cut, the farmer doesn't answer with a plan, but with something he's already lived through.
He remembers a drought about twenty years ago when his municipality, as a holder of rights on the Júcar, had “water to spare” while other areas couldn't irrigate. Instead of keeping the water, they gave it up so other irrigators could use it, and in return accepted one hour less of irrigation a day. “We could still water two hours a day, and that was enough for the orange trees,” he sums up.
Two river basins, two ways of sharing water
The case shows that sharing water between irrigators has been solved before through voluntary transfer, without leaving land uncultivated, in a very different context from today's Tagus-Segura situation, where Scrats is keeping an annulment motion open against the Supreme Court ruling.
- Cost, not flow, is what weighs most on this Júcar irrigator's bill today.
- Sharing water between irrigators already worked twenty years ago without leaving crops unwatered.
- Scrats' annulment motion is still open and will shape what happens in the areas that do depend on the transfer.
Sources: Testimony gathered directly by us.

