LA UNIÓ found plant protection substances not authorised in the European Union in 10 out of 12 batches of citrus bought in supermarkets, 9 of them from South Africa, as we reported on 24 September. Among the substances detected is spirotetramat, sold commercially as Movento. A citrus grower we spoke to, who used the product for years before it was withdrawn, explains what has changed since then in how he treats his own orchards.

“It wasn’t banned for being toxic”

“It really wasn’t banned because it’s toxic, but because the holder, the brand owner, chose not to renew the licence to sell it in Europe,” he explains. The product was mainly used against California red scale, a pest that is only vulnerable to treatment at two very specific times of year: late May and late July, just when the newly hatched insect hasn’t yet grown the shell that protects it from contact products.

Being systemic, Movento worked differently: “it poisoned the plant, in a way, and when the little bug bit, well, it died,” he explains. That meant you could treat even close to harvest because, according to the grower, “it broke down very fast, so it left no residue at all. […] the residue was zero.”

More treatments, more cost

The substitute he uses now works by contact, “like oil, for example,” and needs several passes where one used to be enough. “Of course, this has pushed the price up, because you have to do more treatments,” he sums up, adding that the replacement products “are also very expensive.”

The paperwork hasn’t changed: “any warehouse always asks you for the field log,” which must record the date of each treatment and the product used, so the pre-harvest interval can be checked. In his case, between the last treatment and the start of harvest “a couple of months go by,” well above the required minimum.

Why you don’t see South African fruit next to Spanish fruit

On imported fruit on the shelves, the grower adds a point our 24 September report didn’t cover. Imports from South Africa are allowed until 30 October, but whatever arrives that day keeps being sold until stock runs out, overlapping with the first Spanish navelinas. According to him, last year’s overlap caused such losses that this season “not a single retailer has gone out to buy even one kilo of navelinas.”

He also says he has never seen South African fruit next to Spanish fruit in a shop in Spain, because retailers avoid that overlap: “when the fruit from here comes in, they no longer have South African produce.” Something that, he says, doesn’t happen in the rest of Europe, where buyers “don’t care” about origin: “what they want is good produce, as cheap as possible.”

  • Movento was withdrawn by the manufacturer for commercial reasons, not because of a toxicity alert.
  • Its substitutes require more treatments and drive up production costs.
  • The South African import window closes on 31 October, but its effect on the market lasts well beyond that.

Sources: Imported citrus with banned residues — our own report, 24/09/2026 · Testimony gathered directly by us.

— Redacción Campos del Abuelo