It's happened to you, we're sure. You buy chestnuts that look fantastic, leave them in the kitchen for a couple of days and, when you go to roast them, there's a little round hole and, sometimes, a small white grub wandering around the bag. Our friend Antonio, who grows chestnut trees in a mountain valley, knows that surprise well:

“You take this chestnut to the warehouse right now and maybe three days later it's come out. It's a weevil, like the one in beans.”

It's not carelessness or poor hygiene. It's the natural cycle of some insects that have lived alongside the chestnut tree forever. In this article we'll tell you who that worm is, why it comes out once the chestnut is already at home, how to separate the good ones from the bad, and what farmers and warehouses do to prevent it.

Chestnuts on a kitchen counter, one with a small hole

Who the chestnut worm is

The name “chestnut worm” actually covers two kinds of insects:

  • The chestnut weevil (Curculio elephas), a beetle with an extremely long snout that it uses to bore into the chestnut in summer and lay its eggs inside. This is the weevil Antonio talks about, a relative of the ones that attack pulses and grain.
  • Chestnut moths (Cydia splendana and Cydia fagiglandana), small moths that lay their eggs near the burrs. Once hatched, their caterpillars burrow into the still-green chestnut. In many areas, Cydia splendana does the most damage.

Both have one thing in common: the larva lives and grows inside the chestnut, feeding on it, with no sign at all from the outside.

Why it shows up three days later

This is the key to what Antonio describes. The attack begins in summer, while the burr is still green up in the tree. For weeks the larva grows inside. When the ripe chestnut falls to the ground, the larva is ready to leave. It does so by chewing a round hole, the exit hole, so it can bury itself in the soil, spend the winter there and become an adult the following year.

If by then the chestnut is no longer on the orchard floor but in a crate, a warehouse or your kitchen, the larva comes out anyway. That's why a chestnut that looked healthy when picked can show a hole a few days later. The chestnut didn't go bad in the warehouse: the worm had been inside since summer.

“The chestnut itself produces it. It may or may not. But you've already got it in your glove, you're not stopping at every single one.”

How to tell if a chestnut has a worm

There's no foolproof method, but there are signs that help:

  1. The hole. A clean, round hole means the larva has already left. Moth holes are usually finer than weevil holes.
  2. Squeeze it. A damaged chestnut usually feels a bit softer or hollow when you press it between your fingers.
  3. The base. A dark or rotten base is a bad sign.
  4. The weight. If one chestnut feels much lighter than others the same size, it's probably empty or eaten inside.

Antonio adds an observation from the field: in his experience, wormy chestnuts tend to be smaller, although big ones get them too. That's why lots of small, poor-looking ones are discarded during picking. We talk about sizes in small or large chestnuts: which taste better?

The water test

It's the age-old trick and Antonio uses it too. Tip the chestnuts into a tub of cold water:

Tub of water with chestnuts: the good ones at the bottom and some floating
“The good one sinks.”

Healthy chestnuts, dense and full, go to the bottom. The ones that float are usually empty, dried out or eaten inside, so set them aside. It's a very useful test, but not foolproof: a chestnut whose larva is still small may sink anyway, because it has barely lost any weight.

After the test, dry the chestnuts thoroughly. As Antonio says, water helps, “but then you need to dry it”. A chestnut left damp goes mouldy and black within a few days. We explain it in how to store chestnuts at home.

Chestnuts spread out on a cloth to dry

What warehouses do

Hot water treatment

Antonio has been looking into it for his own project: heat the chestnut, cool it and dry it, “that's when you kill everything”. It's the hydrothermal treatment many warehouses use. The chestnuts are soaked in water at about 50 °C for 45 minutes to an hour, depending on the source. The heat kills the larvae inside and also controls storage fungi. Along the way, any that float are removed. Then they're cooled and dried.

It isn't perfect, because some very small larvae survive or go undetected, but it greatly reduces the problem. The drawback, as Antonio admits, is the investment: you need tanks with temperature-controlled water and a good drying system.

Cold

The other tool is cold. Chestnuts are stored professionally in cold rooms, between −1 and 0 °C with 90 to 95 % relative humidity. At those temperatures the larva stops developing and the chestnut keeps in good condition for weeks or even months. Antonio remembered reading that those temperatures kill the weevil. What they certainly do is slow it down. To actually kill the larva, the most effective option at home is the domestic freezer, at about −18 °C.

You have to be careful not to overdo it in the cold room: European chestnuts freeze below about −2 °C, and accidental freezing ruins their texture if they're later sold as fresh.

Is it dangerous to eat a chestnut with a worm?

No. The larva isn't toxic and doesn't transmit diseases to people. It simply spoils the chestnut: the eaten part is dark, full of debris and tastes bad. If you peel a chestnut and find a tunnel or a black patch, throw it away. The rest from the same batch are perfectly fine to eat.

What you can do at home

  1. Check the chestnuts as soon as you buy them and set aside any with holes or soft spots.
  2. Do the water test and keep the ones that sink. Dry them well afterwards.
  3. Eat them soon or keep them in the fridge, which slows down any larvae that might be inside.
  4. If you're keeping them a long time, freeze them. The freezer kills the larvae and the chestnuts keep for months.
  5. Check each one as you peel. If one has a tunnel, the rest are fine.

Frequently asked questions

Why do worms come out of chestnuts that looked perfect?

Because the larva had been inside since summer. When the chestnut ripens, the larva comes out to bury itself, whether the chestnut is on the forest floor or in your kitchen.

Do wormy chestnuts float?

Many do, because they're empty or eaten, but not all. A chestnut with a still-small larva can sink.

Does freezing chestnuts kill the worm?

Yes. A domestic freezer, at about −18 °C, kills the larvae. The fridge only slows them down.

Are there guaranteed worm-free chestnuts?

No natural chestnut comes with a total guarantee, because the insect is part of the chestnut tree's ecosystem. Sorting in the field, the water test, hot water and cold greatly reduce the problem.

From the chestnut grove to your table

The chestnut is a living fruit, and that has a lovely side and a side that takes work: sorting by hand, one by one, so they reach your home in good condition. We're working with Antonio on a way to bring his freshly picked chestnuts to your door. In the meantime, in Reserve your harvest you'll find the autumn fruit we pick the same day it ships. From the field to the box, and from the box to your home. That simple, that authentic.

Sources

— Eduardo Cifre