La Unió expects 2.59 million tonnes of citrus in the Valencian Community this season, the second-smallest harvest of the last two decades. With less fruit, prices should go up. They don't: Navelina opened on the wholesale market at 0.27 euros per kilo, below production costs. A citrus grower tells us why.

“Yes, this year there are fewer oranges than ever,” he confirms. “Prices are low and they're not going up because there's a huge amount of competition. There are lots of overseas oranges in every market; they're packed with oranges. And with so much competition and such a big gap in wages and everything else, the truth is they buy at rock-bottom prices.”

The data backs up his diagnosis. The EU imported 1.57 million tonnes of citrus from non-EU countries last season, 14.9% more than the year before and an all-time record. Fruit from outside now covers 26.5% of Europe's supply, compared with 18.4% ten years ago. In easy peelers, South Africa is the top supplier, with 27.7%.

“The warehouses stockpile”

South African competition, in his experience, doesn't end when the import season does. “Of course you feel the competition from South Africa. And not just in September and October, because September and October are the months when it can be imported, but what the warehouses do is stockpile, and throughout November they keep selling South African fruit. That's one of the tricks out there.”

That stored fruit overlaps with the first Valencian varieties. “It competes with the first varieties coming in here. And if you add to that the fact that the first varieties are very early and not premium quality, it's causing quite a few problems.”

It's the same reason the citrus map is changing. In Castellón, early clementine production will drop 10.6% this season, while hybrid mandarins, picked in December and January, will rise 25.9%. Carles Peris, secretary general of La Unió, puts it down to early fruit being sold “at the same time as the pressure from South African fruit on European markets.”

Switching varieties: 800 euros and five years

This grower farms traditional clementines and would switch if he could. “If I could, I'd switch to modern varieties. The thing is, they all carry royalties and the investment is huge.”

There are two routes, and neither is cheap. “To replant you have to pull out and plant, or graft. Grafting costs less, but it also depends on the state of the orchard, whether the trees are young or old. You have to weigh that up.”

He puts numbers on the full option: “Not counting the royalty, replanting can cost between 600 and 800 euros per hanegada, just for pulling out, preparing the land, buying the plants and planting.”

And then, the wait. “From there you have to wait four or five years to get a decent yield and start bringing money in. Those are all years of investment.”

Selling “a resultas”: “a trap”

How you sell matters as much as the price. He's clear about it: “I sell at a fixed price.”

He explains the difference between buyers: “A private trader can't buy without a price. There has to be a set price in the contract.” It's a different story at cooperatives and producer groups, where a member's fruit can be settled “a resultas”, that is, at whatever price it fetches once it's sold.

His verdict on that system is harsh: “Selling a resultas, whether in cooperatives or producer groups, means the farmer ends up with nothing, because he can't control the sales or anything else. He has to believe what the company tells him and, in the end, the companies set the profit they want and the farmer is always left with what's left: nothing.”

“Selling a resultas is a trap for the farmer,” he sums up, “because, apart from being prohibited by law, it can only be done in cooperatives and warehouses under a special condition.”

What the law says

The Food Chain Law backs him up. It requires every contract with a producer to set the price “based solely on objective, verifiable, non-manipulable factors,” and that price must be “in all cases, higher than the total costs borne by the producer” (article 9). The exception is deliveries that members make to their own cooperatives and associative entities, which the law doesn't consider commercial relationships (article 2).

That obligation clashes with this season's figures. Navelina is trading on the wholesale market at 0.27 euros per kilo, and AVA-ASAJA puts its break-even point at 0.32.

The Conselleria's official crop estimate, still to be published, will show whether the harvest is as small as the farmers' organisations expect.


Sources: Agroinformación — The second-smallest harvest of the last two decades · Economía 3 — The citrus season signs blind in a record year for imports · Castellón Plaza — Clementines lose ground to more profitable varieties · BOE — Law 12/2013 on the food chain

— Redacción Campos del Abuelo